Optimism about President Obama's higher education tax reform proposals

By Kim Rueben and Sandy Baum  ::  January 26th, 2015


This post originally appeared on the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center's blog, TaxVox.

President Obama will feature higher education prominently in next week’s budget—a choice that makes sense, given that educational attainment is the most straightforward pathway for economic advancement. Many of his ideas, which he highlighted in his State of the Union address, are controversial. And some don’t go far enough. But they’d do a better job helping households who most need education assistance than the current complex array of programs.

Obama would restructure both spending and tax subsidies for higher education. Sandy Baum and Judith Scott-Clayton have commented on Obama’s plan for free community college education. But many of his ideas are aimed at tax subsidies. While replacing those tax programs with direct support would be more effective, the president’s proposals would go a long way towards simplifying the existing system. The tax code’s 14 tax preferences for higher education complicate filing and discourage people from choosing the most effective form of government assistance.

It’s important consider what these programs should be doing. Should they be aimed at reducing costs for students who’d be going to college anyway? Or at expanding access to those who would otherwise not enroll? If that’s the primary aim is the latter—and it should be—the system need to be easier to navigate and better targeted to low- and middle-income households.

The best way to do that through the tax code is to replace deductions with credits—preferably refundable credits-- so that the size of subsidy does not increase with income. By that standard, the President would improve the current system.

Existing tax preferences provide assistance before, during, and after attending school. The President’s plan addresses them all. Let’s take them in order.

Before: Obama’s proposal to reduce tax preferences for Sec. 529-type college savings plans is getting a lot of attention. While supporters argue that tax-free savings encourages college attendance, the plans are regressive and poorly designed. While we know little about the students who benefit from the accounts, there is no question that the savings plans primarily benefit high-income parents or other family members.

Because low-income households pay little or no federal income tax, the tax exemption doesn’t help them at all. Higher-income families are saving anyway, and their children are already the most likely to go to college. According to estimates based on the 2013 Survey of Current Finance data, only about 3 percent of families participate in 529-type plans and over 70 percent of accounts comprising 87 percent of the balances are held by taxpayers earning over $100,000; almost 70 percent of balances are held by the 6.4 percent of households earning over $200,000.

During: The President would simplify, consolidate and better target tax benefits received during college. He’d eliminate the Lifetime Learning Credit and the tuition and fees deduction, while expanding the American Opportunity Tax Credit that now provides a partially refundable credit for the first four years of postsecondary education. Currently limited to degree-seeking students enrolled at least half time, the credit is the most generous preference for most families in terms of both size and the range of expenses it covers. Obama would not only consolidate these subsidies into a single simple credit, he’d expand eligibility to five years and allow a refundable credit for less than half-time attendance— changes that make the credit more in keeping with the typical time frame of low-income students.

The President would also make tax-free the portion of Pell Grants used for living expenses. As a result, recipients could use tuition expenses to qualify for the AOTC and use their Pell Grants to cover living expenses that don’t qualify for the credit.

After: While the return on the investment in college is generally high, some graduates struggle with large student debt. While Obama would eliminate the current deduction for student loan interest, he’d shift the subsidy to a tax exemption for any forgiven debt under the already adopted income-based loan repayment plan. This too would better target assistance to those who need it most.

The President’s proposals move in the right direction. They do a better job of targeting subsidies to students of limited means and save money by curbing tax benefits now available to high-income households, whose children would likely go to college without government assistance.

The best education policy would subsidize education through direct spending on programs such as Pell Grants and loan relief rather than with tax breaks. Direct aid is easier to target, easier to deliver in a timely manner, and easier to understand. But if we are going to continue to rely on the tax system to subsidize college education, the president’s reforms would improve the targeting and effectiveness of educational aid.

- See more at: http://taxvox.taxpolicycenter.org/2015/01/26/obama-improve-tax-subsidies-higher-education/#sthash.farWOxUj.dpuf

Aligning housing and health services for seniors: another step forward

By Pam Blumenthal and Matthew Johnson  ::  January 23rd, 2015

As the baby boomer generation ages, concerns of a “silver tsunami” have grown. But there is a critical difference between an actual tsunami and a metaphorical tide of aging Americans: We can see this coming and we can prepare for it. While we are not fully prepared to meet the housing and health needs of [...]

Read More


Four important considerations regarding the free community college proposal

By Sandy Baum and Judith Scott-Clayton  ::  January 22nd, 2015

President Obama’s proposal to eliminate tuition for America’s community college students could be a case study in the messaging power of “free.” It has caught people’s attention in a way that prior efforts to lower the price of college have not. Googling “Obama free community college” returns a whopping 75 million results, compared with 92,500 for [...]

Read More


President Obama's middle class tax message in the State of the Union

By Eugene Steuerle  ::  January 22nd, 2015

Versions of this post originally appeared on Gene Steuerle’s Government We Deserve Blog and on the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center’s TaxVox blog. President Obama’s tax proposals for the middle class were a key element of his State of the Union address. But they represent only relatively modest efforts to create subsidies through the tax code rather [...]

Read More


How to create meaningful and lasting change in state government

By Heather Hahn and Ria Amin  ::  January 21st, 2015

A few years ago, the worst government social service offices in Illinois had rodents, broken lights, and piles of paper so massive that staff literally could not see over them. Needy families seeking help from these offices faced long wait times, lost mail, and unanswered phones. Since then, the Illinois Department of Human Services has [...]

Read More

Projecting our country’s demographic future: The truth may be stranger than fiction

By Kait Hildner  ::  January 21st, 2015

For months, my colleagues and I worked to build a population projection tool called Mapping America’s Futures. As we reviewed the results from different assumptions, we came across some implausible outcomes. Was there a problem in the coding, in the assumptions? Can the population of a commuting zone, for example, really grow to 1.5 times [...]

Read More

Four impacts of the Federal Housing Administration's premium cut

By Karan Kaul and Bing Bai  ::  January 21st, 2015

President Obama’s recent announcement that mortgage insurance premiums for Federal Housing Administration (FHA) mortgages will decrease from 1.35 percent to 0.85 percent is welcome news for prospective FHA borrowers. This half-a-percentage-point reduction is particularly meaningful because it comes as mortgage rates are once again approaching record lows. The potential for cost savings and the resulting [...]

Read More

Thinking about our country's demographic future: Projections and policy

By Pam Blumenthal  ::  January 20th, 2015

In the last two weeks, President Obama has identified several new policies to address national challenges, such as making mortgage loans more affordable by lowering FHA premiums and increasing access to education by offering free tuition at community colleges. Immigration reform is occurring through administrative action while the potential for legislative action continues. These and [...]

Read More


We're live-tweeting tonight’s State of the Union address. Join us!

By Nicole Levins  ::  January 20th, 2015

The state of the union is… a great time to get on social media and talk about policy. Tonight at 9pm ET, join @urbaninstitute and a number of our policy experts as we live-tweet President Obama’s State of the Union address. Watch the conversation unfold below, and share your own thoughts on Twitter using the [...]

Read More