Use your widget sidebars in the admin Design tab to change this little blurb here. Add the text widget to the Blurb Sidebar!
Home Commentary Metropolitan Spotlights Dashboard Data Maps Blog Subscribe to MetroTrends Blog - RSS RSS icon

When Poverty Grows in the Metro, it Grows in Both Cities and Suburbs

Author: Rolf Pendall

| Posted: August 3rd, 2011

Much attention has been paid in recent years to the suburbanization of poverty. Some attribute this change to policies aimed at making low-income people more mobile, including HOPE VI and housing choice vouchers. Sometimes, the list of forces behind suburban poverty growth extends to displacement of low-income people from revitalized or gentrified central-city neighborhoods.

Like the rebound of concentrated poverty in metropolitan America since 2000, however, suburban poverty growth reflects spreading metropolitan poverty more than urban policy, housing policy, or housing demand in a few neighborhoods. A city in a metro area where poverty grew in the 2000s had less than one chance in ten of avoiding some poverty growth. That rate held regardless of city size, so being a central city or large city certainly didn’t protect jurisdictions from poverty growth. This same pattern holds in other jurisdiction types. More than nine out of ten unincorporated counties and townships, regardless of their population, also saw poverty grow if their metro area’s poverty rate was rising. Since poverty grew in 809 of the nation’s 938 metro and micropolitan areas in the 2000s, both the suburbanization and the urbanization of poverty were  facts of life throughout America in the 2000s.

Take Detroit. Most of its suburbs saw poverty growth between 2000 and 2007; only a handful of small affluent enclaves and exurbs didn’t. The City of Detroit, however, added over 50,000 poor residents in the 2000s even as its population fell by over 35,000. Poverty also grew in every other large city in the region, including Warren, Sterling Heights, and Livonia, all cities over 100,000 residents. All this occurred against a backdrop of widespread population decline—that is, the number of people in poverty grew, as the total population fell.

The biggest single increase in urban poverty in the early 2000s didn’t happen in Detroit, however, but in Houston, which added over 60,000 people in poverty between 2000 and 2007 as its metro area’s poverty rate grew by five percentage points. Considering the metro area’s huge population increase and its reputation for a vibrant economy, this growth in poverty may come as a surprise.  More recent Census estimates now show that by 2009, the number of Houston city residents in poverty had grown to nearly 460,000: almost 200,000 more people than in 2000. Galveston, meanwhile, lost poor people to evacuation in the wake of Hurricane Ike, echoing the much higher magnitude of depopulation and displacement of the poor from New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina. But again, the other big cities in the Houston metro area—even affluent Sugar Land—have seen poverty increase in both absolute and percent terms since the decade began.

Other central cities that saw populations of the poor soar between 2000 and 2007 included Dallas, Phoenix, Indianapolis, Columbus, San Antonio, Austin, Fort Worth, and El Paso. All have their own stories, but they differ from the one I’ll return to in a future blog: suburban poverty in America’s three largest metro areas.

Filed under: Economic development, Economic well-being, Houston, Income and Benefits Policy Center, Income and Wealth, Low-Income Working Families, Metro, Metropolitan Housing and Communities Policy Center
13 Comments »

13 Comments on “When Poverty Grows in the Metro, it Grows in Both Cities and Suburbs”

  1. 1 justine v said at 9:12 am on August 3rd, 2011:

    Frightening that out of the ten cities cited, six were in Texas. Curious what state policies and demographic trends led to this situation.

  2. 2 okra said at 1:28 pm on August 4th, 2011:

    Perhaps because many former residents of New Orleans moved to Houston and other Texas cities after Katrina?

  3. 3 Rolf Pendall said at 4:29 pm on August 4th, 2011:

    Interesting question about the role of Katrina. Between 100,000 and 150,000 New Orleanians were displaced to Houston, I think, but many of these were not below poverty and some returned to New Orleans. But we’ll take a look at the numbers and get back to this next time.

  4. 4 Houston experiences largest growth of poor population in American metros | Texas housers said at 8:03 am on August 5th, 2011:

    [...] These are the observations of Rolf Pendall, PhD, Director of the Metropolitan Housing & Communities Policy Center at the Urban Institute, writing in the blog MetroTrends. [...]

  5. 5 Whitney said at 7:37 pm on August 8th, 2011:

    My initial reaction, too, was that a large portion of the increase in poverty in Houston could be attributed to people moving to Houston after Katrina and Rita. To prove/disprove this idea, it would be helpful to see what the increase in poverty was 2000 – 2004 and then 2004 – 2005 or 2006 since that is when people arrived. I would be curious, too, to see the actual breakdown of rate of poverty of people who moved after Katrina and Rita, and the possible increase in poverty even among those groups as they had difficulty finding employment, etc. in Houston.

    As for the other Texas cities growing in poverty, I think this data goes hand-in-hand with the recent national coverage about the large portion of new jobs in Texas being very low-wage jobs and the compounding cuts to mental health care and social supports through the Texas legislature during this period.

    http://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2011/07/17/the-texas-jobs-juggernaut/the-minimum-wage-trap-in-texas

    Thanks for taking on this important work!

  6. 6 (4) Everything really is big in Texas… | suburban-poverty.com said at 12:54 am on August 9th, 2011:

    [...] to the Texas suburbs Houston experiences largest growth of poor populations in American metros When poverty grows in the metro, it grows in both city and suburbs This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged poverty, statistics, Texas, United States by [...]

  7. 7 Confronting suburban poverty – or celebrating suburban resilience? said at 1:04 pm on June 6th, 2013:

    [...] tells is about the higher poverty growth rates in the suburbs. However, growing suburban poverty is tracking increases in national and metropolitan poverty rates. The questions then become, why does suburban poverty [...]

  8. 8 Confronting sububan poverty – or celebrating suburban resilience? « The Berkeley Blog said at 10:39 pm on June 6th, 2013:

    [...] tells is about the higher poverty growth rates in the suburbs. However, growing suburban poverty is tracking increases in national and metropolitan poverty rates. The questions then become, why does suburban poverty [...]

  9. 9 Ding Dong the New Deal’s Dead: Poverty Expands to Suburbs « The WILD Magazine said at 10:00 am on June 13th, 2013:

    [...] poverty normally reflects the spread of metropolitan poverty, but in recent years, suburban poverty has been growing at a faster rate. [...]

  10. 10 POVERTY IN SUBURBIA: THE RISE OF THE OUTER CITY POOR | Welcome to the Doctor's Office said at 4:01 pm on June 22nd, 2013:

    [...] poverty normally reflects the spread of metropolitan poverty, but in recent years, suburban poverty has been growing at a faster rate. [...]

  11. 11 Environmental, Health and Safety News – Poverty in Suburbia: Rise of Outer City Poor via @SocImages & @TheWILDmagazine said at 11:51 am on June 23rd, 2013:

    [...] poverty normally reflects the spread of metropolitan poverty, but in recent years, suburban poverty has been growing at a faster [...]

  12. 12 Christopher A. Haase » Blog Archive » Poverty in Suburbia: Rise of Outer City Poor via @SocImages & @TheWILDmagazine said at 7:03 am on June 27th, 2013:

    [...] poverty normally reflects the spread of metropolitan poverty, but in recent years, suburban poverty has been growing at a faster [...]

  13. 13 The Rise of the Suburban Poor - said at 3:02 pm on August 8th, 2013:

    [...] poverty normally reflects the spread of metropolitan poverty, but in recent years, suburban poverty has been growing at a faster rate. [...]


Leave a Reply